October 11, 2025
The Most Common Mistake With Bison

We hear it a lot. Someone orders for the first time, cooks it like a grocery-store ribeye, and ends up with something dry and tough. Then they decide bison isn’t for them, when they just cooked it too long.
Bison has about 25 to 30% less fat than beef. A beef steak has fat running through it that keeps it moist even if you go past medium. Bison doesn’t have that cushion, so take it off early.
The Numbers
Cook steaks and roasts to 145°F inside, the USDA’s safe minimum, and let them rest 3 minutes. Ground bison should reach 160°F. Going much past those numbers is where bison dries out.
- Ribeye: about 3 minutes a side on a hot grill
- Tenderloin: closer to 2½ minutes a side
- Burgers: 3 to 4 minutes a side, to 160°F
- Chuck roast: about 20 minutes a pound at 350°F, to 145°F
Check the temperature early and often, and take the meat off as soon as it gets there. Then let it rest at least 3 minutes before you cut it.
Buy a Thermometer
A decent instant-read thermometer costs $15 to $20. An overcooked bison steak wastes good meat and makes a bad first impression. We’ve raised bison for almost 20 years, and getting a thermometer is still the advice we give most.
